Porn Worth Paying For: What Makes You Open Your Wallet?

It’s no secret that the digital revolution has hit Porn Valley pretty hard: even without piracy, the ease of digital distribution and massive glut of free content has made it harder to convince consumers to shell out for smut.

Which creates a bit of a problem—at least if you’re the type of person who sees value in professionally produced porn (like our friends at Digital Playground, who care so much about their work that they’ve actually trademarked the phrase “Porn worth paying for” and use it as their slogan). If porn companies have no income coming in, it becomes increasingly difficult to fund output going out; and though we doubt that Porn Valley will ever be completely stopped in its tracks, it seems likely that some sort of massive culling of porn companies may soon be upon us.

And so porn companies are finding themselves at a crossroads: if they plan on staying in business, they need to figure out what the future holds for porn—and, more specifically, what future (and current) consumers will be willing to pay for. Being the curious souls that we are, we, too, would like to know what kind of porn you see as spendworthy.

The strategies we’ve seen seem to break down as follows:

Super feature-packed DVDs: The switch to Blu-Ray is one of the most current incarnations of this strategy, but it’s a trend that’s been going on for awhile. In order to get consumers to pay for porn DVDs, companies attempt to give them more bang for their buck, as it were: extended BTS, cum shot compilations, the ability to select by position, and so on. The much ballyhooed 3D porn seems to be the next big thing—but will it actually make you pay? [Image courtesy of UndressJess.com]

High-quality feature porn films. The feature itself is hardly a new thing, but some companies are betting that it’s the best bet at staying afloat—particularly if it’s, say, a parody of a popular sitcom that’s sure to get loads of mainstream attention. With its big budget and even bigger marketing campaign, Digital Playground’s “Pirates 2″ is the most prominent example of this, but smaller features like “Scrubs – A XXX Parody” are still included under the umbrella. [Image from "Pirates 2" courtesy of Digital Playground]

VOD and pay-per-scene. If you had to buy an entire cow every time you wanted a glass of milk, you’d probably become much less interested in ingesting dairy. Some companies are betting that that’s how quite a few consumers see porn: why buy a four hour compilation when all you want is that one twenty minute scene? VOD and pay-per-scene offer the ability to buy just the bits you want—without having to pay for the filler. [Image via Big Boobs In Your Face]

Niche content. Pink and White Productions—the geniuses behind the Crash Pad Series and “Champion”—isn’t one of Porn Valley’s top five studios, but it is a sustainable, profitable company. Ditto Burning Angel, our Supreme Commandress Joanna Angel’s hot punk porn company. Providing small, specific groups with something they desperately want—and can’t find anywhere else—could be a good way to stay afloat in these troubling times.

Community. Cliche though it may sound, there are in fact people who’ve joined SuicideGirls, not for the naked pictures, but for the close knit community. Providing an environment in which members can interact with their crush objects (as well as ogling them naked) might just be the extra incentive to get them to pay.

So which of the above—if any—are enough to tug at your wallet strings? Inquiring minds are dying to know! (And if there’s something we’ve forgotten, feel free to tell us in the comments.)

Tags: , , , , , ,

  • atlas

    id pay for all of it, although i dont. i was going to buy my first porn dvd just last week, looked at the prices and laughed and went to download instead.

  • trekkie

    I tend to pay for decent ‘plot driven’ feature types more than anything. I’ve tried others and it feels more of a rip off for the price that the DVDs go for. Some of it has terrible acting but at least for us they seem to work the best.

    VOD and other stuff has challenges, as sometimes when the internet connection isn’t working right in the bedroom it kinda ruins it, and I don’t like re-paying for content I’ve paid for the first time. The quality has got to be at least DVD level on a 15 – 20″ display too. A lot of VOD type stuff is heavily compressed and 320×200 quality.

    why yes, i’ve given this thought before

  • hodayathink is walking in the glow of love

    You kinda forgot professionally produced internet porn (videos). I don’t really pay for features because the prices are exorbitant (I’m not paying more for a porn DVD than I would pay for a Hollywood movie. Just no. I’ll go watch softcore instead). But I will pay $25 a month for a website (network) that produces that produces at least 20-30 hours of content in that month, plus access to hundreds or thousands of hours of already shot content, all of which I can keep on my computer (or burn to DVD, if I’m so inclined) even after I stop paying membership fees.

  • Mick

    Gonzo is the only way to go. Features tend to place too much emphasis on a stylized version of intimate time when just getting down to the grind is what most people just want. All the other options for viewing porn have pricing issues that need to be adjusted before they replace the DVD format we love know and love.

  • Uli_Kunkel

    It sorta goes along with community, but I think branding goes a pretty long way in terms of places that I would give my support. I’m planning on buying the popporn DVD when it comes out because I like those guys’ approach and think they deserve the cash. Quite honestly, I’d do the same damn thing if fleshbot were ever to put out a series. (hint hint)

  • Conrad

    As it is now I mostly just buy the hard to find classics. Hard to find as far as seeders are concerned.

  • Anonymous

    I’m all about the niche content. Those are the people I want to give my money to- the little(r) guys who need my dollars and who are kind of fighting to promote non-mainstream porn/aesthetics. The fact that you can’t get it elsewhere for free tends to really make me open my wallet fast.

    Quality and a company’s mission are also big ones for me- I’m much happier to part with money to a site like Kink.com than another BDSM site, just because their values appeal to me immensely.

    Features are fun, but truth be told, I’d rather VOD stream-rent them for extremely cheap and then, if I like it, buy the DVD. It always seems like you’re taking a chance with features.

  • sam991

    For me there are two categories of performers: Those i will gladly pay to be a member of their website (eg Justine Joli) and those whose scenes i will pick up if the movie looks good. So pay-per-scene, as you put it, makes sense. I’d rather pay $10 for Gianna Michaels scene in Big Natural Titties 3 than $50 for the entire feature.

    The exception to this as a few others have mentioned is the standout series, for example Big Wet Asses. That i will pick up religiously because i know the content will be good.

  • MindTricked

    Who pays for porn nowadays?

    *looks around, hears crickets*

    But seriously… well-crafted feature porn is far more enjoyable to me, and even worth paying for (if it has that high quality to it). It also tends to be the most expensive, as opposed to the latest gonzo, which can usually be bought on the cheap (comparatively-speaking). The old adage is usually true, though – you get what you pay for – but one takes a chance with the feature, whereas one usually knows what one is getting with Ass Worship.

    I don’t know… there has to be a happy medium in there somewhere – HQ feature with gonzo-style sex. Throw random niche stuff in their for added attractiveness, edit it in such a way that it can’t be cut up into bits for various web site streams/downloads, and you might have something truly worth buying.

  • Anonymous

    I’m happy to pay for a quality website that’s full of great content. I’m seriously considering getting with plumperpass.com. Until then, I’m content with hanging out at a couple of BBW/FA forums and renting the few BBW-themed titles that come to my local spot. And I wish there were more of those that were worth my time and money.

  • SnowDude

    I’d pay for good niche content, but have trouble finding it! Any good “hard to find niche” niche sites out there?

  • artusamak

    @Lux Alptraum: The music industry is good precedent. Allowing people to buy individual tracks from online stores that had millions of obscure tracks gave the consumer choice. Aside from piracy, consumers were given the option to buy an individual track for $0.99 instead of buying a whole album for $15. There’s something similar going on in porn, only instead of buying clips, people find their happy ending in 2-3-5 minutes for free on the internet. Back in the day, when we oldsters had no other options, buying the physical product (Playboy, Penthouse, VHS tapes, and then DVDs) was really the only alternative. Now people can get the porn equivalent of an individual track for free at countless sites. So we shouldn’t be surprised that the porn industry’s revenue is crashing. It’ll probably reinvent itself in a financially viable way…but I don’t know how or when. Big portions of it might die off before the change happens.

  • I.M.B.Y What’s THIS for…!

    I.E.B.N. The only porn I have paid for in the last 3 years is their streaming content and the DVD’s I find on it. I consider the whole site a “try before you buy” godsend. I have bought more than a few DVD’s after making sure it was hot enough through I.E.B.N.

    It plays like the mutli-channel peeps like they had in Times Square years ago except you can scroll through a scene to see if it is even worth playing through in real time. Best idea for porn yet, IMHO

  • Anonymous

    I have had paid memberships at sites like brazzers, realitlykings, Pornpros, NA and Killergram (great UK site) before. I normally stay for a few months and then get bored and want some more niche stuff and end up cancelling. Then get bored with niche stuff and the lack of updates and go back to the big sites.

    In between I end up going for the free stuff. Features bore me, if I wanted to watch a film I’d watch a film, for porn I don’t want plot, I like a little lead up like the brazzer stuff but if there isn’t action in the first 5 minutes I’m off.

    It’d be nice if the big sites did niche stuff better, a MILF/teacher and a MILF/Mom’s friend site aren’t 2 different sites. Maybe if they could license scenes from the niche site, maybe delayed from the niche site so those really into something still have reasons to go there. If they did I think they’d retain more business as people get bored of the Teen/MILF/Big Tits gravy train. A bit of varity would go a long way.