Beyond The Pornodome: Stoya Vs. Mika Tan

In some ways, the choice between Mika Tan and Stoya represents one of the oldest decisions we’ve ever had to make, one that’s plagued us since high school. Do we go with the elegant, alt chick with the classically beautiful look, or the down and dirty girl who’s always up for some naughty fun (and hates shoulder stink)? (Actually, both these girls seem to be up for some naughty fun, but you know what we mean.) Now that we spend our days savoring every last bit of adult entertainment, we no longer have to make that choice—we’re able to enjoy each star equally, admiring all their wonderful charms to the fullest possible extent. But this isn’t real life, it’s Extreme Pornstar Showdown. So make your choice, kids: will you side with Stoya? Or will Mika be your champion? The choice is yours, after the jump.

. . .

Mika Tan


· Mika Tan, the softest Asian mouth (pornhub.com)

Stoya


· Stoya, Brianna Love, and Manuel Ferrera in “Cheerleaders” (digitalplayground.com)

Gawker Media polls require Javascript; if you’re viewing this in an RSS reader, click through to view in your Javascript-enabled web browser.

Last Week’s Winner: Jenna Haze

*****

Previously: Extreme Pornstar Showdown Archives

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

  • evan_phi

    Mika, solely based on the fact that I hate seeing ribs when a girl is STANDING!

  • Brian47

    Mika Tan has rocked my world for years, I am fiercely loyal to her all-around fierceness! :)

  • Anonymous

    I love hot ribs

  • MalzyWheels

    OK…I give up…which one is the “down and dirty girl”? =)

  • Anonymous

    Stoya always left me a bit cold in her scenes but then I saw coverage of her being ‘normal’ in a few Pop Porn videos and realised that, actually, she seemed pretty cool.

    Which is probably kind of wrong, but, what can you do?

  • Wetzilla

    Though I know it’s hopeless for her, I do love my Mika Tan

  • Snowbunny

    Mika Tan is a goddess of non-existant gag reflexes. I LOVE her work.

  • Tranari

    What can I say, Stoya does things to me that have nothing to do with sex and porn. It’s not a fair fight with her in the mix. Mika could be the greatest pornstar on earth and it would be to no avail.

  • Ecks

    I wasn’t really familiar with either girl’s work, but based on the above clips, gotta pick Stoya – the whole on the toilet thing is a bit too crappy.

  • Anonymous

    I think both ladies are spectacular, but I have to give the edge to Ms. Tan for her most excellent head game.

  • Anonymous

    I’m surprise how many votes Mika Tan got. It’s extremely low. It doesn’t matter she is still the best in this match up.

  • Anonymous

    Stoya, most definitely.

    On another note, I wish there was a ban on saying things like “suck that cock” in pornos. That simply drives me nuts. Is the guy afraid the woman has a terribly short attention span and forget what she’s doing?

  • Anonymous

    How is this even a contest? I mean Mika’s a hottie, but there are very few women that can even hold a candle to Stoya.

  • Anonymous

    STOYA!

  • Anonymous

    Stoya is smoking hot…Mika is not.

  • FinalFist

    Stoya just has more going for her, she somehow manages innocent while getting fucked in the ass! And somehow her paleness I find oddly attractive.

  • Anonymous

    Wow, I can’t believe what a blowout this is. I love Mika Tan, and this is breaking my heart. :( Again, not blown away by skinny girls.

  • Tsuru

    STOYA and those sexy little tatas!

  • Anonymous

    Stoya, without even thinking!

  • Anonymous

    Stoya for sure, her facial expression and the noises she makes are much better to hear than than the usual, “suck this” or fuck that ass” Although she does say that every now and again it’s not every 5 seconds.

    She also genuinely attractive, and 100% natural unlike 90% of other pornstars.

    While I do have a soft spot for some of those lovely Asian ladies, Mika just doesn’t do it for me.

  • Anonymous

    Stoya, she’s too sexy, natural and perv.

  • Anonymous

    I said STOYA D O L L ]