September 25, 2008 | 22 Comments

Freckled Face Off: Faye Valentine Vs. Penny Flame

Our love of freckled gals is well documented. So how could we not have a very special freckled edition of Extreme Pornstar Showdown? Stepping into the ring this week are Penny Flame and Faye Valentine, two of the finest specimens of freckled femaledom we know. Each girl certainly has her charms: fresh faced Faye definitely dominates on the freckle front, and has some serious crossover appeal. Penny, however, has a spunky attitude, directorial chops, and some serious “Guitar Hero” skills. So who will it be? The choice is yours! Just remember: whoever wins this round will go on to face Gianna Michaels in round two. (Let’s just hope no one chickens out this time, OK?) Choose your victor wisely after the jump.

. . .

Faye Valentine


Faye Valentine fucked (megarotic.com)

Penny Flame


Penny Flame fucking in a pink dress (megarotic.com)

Gawker Media polls require Javascript; if you’re viewing this in an RSS reader, click through to view in your Javascript-enabled web browser.

Last Week’s Winner: Joanna Angel!

* * * * *

Previously: Extreme Pornstar Showdown Archives

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Author:Lux Alptraum

View all posts by Lux Alptraum →
  • hodayathink is walking in the glow of love

    This is the first one that’s not even close for me. Go Penny!

  • Anonymous

    Faye all the way.

  • Anonymous

    My question is how are you gonna have a freckled face off and not have Charlotte Stokely in it??

    She’s my write in vote.

  • Anonymous

    I adore both of these women, but I think with Faye it’s almost entirely objectified (yes, I do realize we’re talking about porn) but with Penny there’s a whole lot of personality that goes into what I love about her.

    I love to watch either of them fuck whenever I can, but I know it’d be a gas just to hang with Penny. She wins.

  • Orgasmatron

    Penny has all the qualities of a great and classic pornstar. She is so completely gorgeous, cute, sassy and oh so fuckable. She’s got mad skills, moves all the right ways and makes all the right sounds when she’s giving it up. Really, what more is there to want from a Pornstar? Totally in the top five, without question.

  • Anonymous

    Mmmm, freckles. Penny Flame does it for me.

  • Anonymous

    Penny gets my vote. That musical laugh when he penetrates her, her obvious enjoyment of the sex and the fact that she kisses him (don’t seem to see that much much in porn) did it for me.

  • likefunbutnot

    Faye is teh awesome.

  • Anonymous

    Penny, no question. Hope she eventually gives up the ass! I’m there.

  • MalzyWheels

    This is the hardest one for me yet, especially if the winner’s going to go up against Gianna next round (ooof!). Penny’s the spunky one for sure, and probably the better starlet, but I just can’t help to be drawn to Faye. If I had access to both of them, in a day to day setting, I think I’d be more apt to try to get into Faye’s pants. The milky skin and freckles just do it for me.

    Oh, since last weeks Shinanigans were brought up, is there any way we can place side bets on who’ll have the next hissy fit? Honestly, I never had the wildest notion that someone would get offended by all this when I made my suggestion.

  • Spyder01

    Faye wins hands down ;)

  • Ecks

    As lovely as Faye Valentine is, Penny Flame surpasses her, sheerly due to her body of work.

  • dirtybacon

    Yeah, too me this is a no-brainer. I’m surprised at how close it is this early. GO PENNY GO!

  • Come a little Miroslav Klose You’re My Kind of Man

    My first poll voting for the savvier veteran. (De Armond-Angel I would have been a game-time decision, but by the time I got to the polling-station, the decision had been rendered via forfeit.) Do appreciate the abundance of freckles on Ms Valentine, but the nod goes to her rival, Ms Flame, for effusiveness.

  • Anonymous

    Hey, Penny Flame, I remember you. I was gonna vote for you one time. But voting isn’t cool. So I stayed home alone and got trashed on listerine.”

  • caffeinequeen

    I’m going with Faye because she’s obviously a Cowboy Bebop fan!

  • Brian47

    Tristan Taormino’s “Chemistry 4″ made me fall in love hard with Penny Flame, so no contest for me… :)

  • MalzyWheels

    Oh yeah…What pink dress???

  • stoya

    Penny’s my favorite.

  • Anonymous

    penny is just delicious

  • Anonymous

    Fay….for the freckles… I thing this girl will be covered in freckles if she is reckless in the sun…I love it.

  • dirtybacon

    Wow, when was the last time the ‘bot had two pages of comments?